SwitchesMEDIUM INTEREST
Melody Redux Switch (IC)
Melody Redux is a light tactile mechanical keyboard switch designed by PuNkShoO and manufactured by BSUN. It features a full POM housing, long pole stem, and factory lubrication for a smooth and unique typing experience.
14 replies
5,448 views
28 Oct 2024
Community Sentiment
14 votes
Positive36%
Neutral21%
Negative43%
Get instant alerts · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Project Gallery
Sentiment Analysis
14
Total Votes
14
Feedback Items
36%
21%
43%
Positive (36%)
Neutral (21%)
Negative (43%)
Positive Feedback
- Excitement about the potential improvements over the previous version.
- Hope for capturing the magic of the original Melody switch.
- Support for the creator's transparency in handling previous switch issues.
- General enthusiasm for the new switch design and community engagement.
- Positive anticipation regarding the collaboration with an experienced manufacturer.
Negative Feedback
- Concerns about the manufacturer (BSUN) and past quality issues.
- Frustration over the handling of previous switch problems and resolutions.
- Skepticism regarding the new switch's performance compared to the original.
- Criticism of the past customer service responses to issues.
- Doubts about the quality control of BSUN's recent products.
- Disappointment regarding the lack of a linear version.
Common Questions
- Why was BSUN chosen as the manufacturer given their recent issues?
- Can we expect a linear version in the future?
- Will switches be offered unlubed?
🤖 AI Summary
The thread had a moderate level of engagement with a total of 11 comments. The feedback is varied, with a balanced mixture of support and criticism regarding the project's past issues and the new manufacturer. Overall, while there is excitement, skepticism also affects the sentiment.
Interest Check Info
AuthorPuNkShoO
Published28 Oct 2024
Last Updated05 Jan 2026
Replies14
Views5,448
Project Specs
NameMelody Redux Switch
Release year2024
Switch typeLight Tactile
Profile
Actuation force60g
Bottom out force
Pre travel3.4mm
Total travel
Pins
Top Housing MaterialPOM
Bottom Housing MaterialPOM
Stem MaterialPOM
Sound profileFull yet muted
Spring typeLong
Weight
Factory lubedtrue
Magnetic Hall Effectfalse
Double stagefalse
Long poletrue
Dust prooffalse
Water resistantfalse