KeycapMEDIUM INTEREST

GMK Marina

This is the creator's first interest check (IC) on GH for the GMK Marina keycaps. They are currently developing the ISO and Spacebar expansions. Feedback is encouraged to improve the project.

17 replies

7,208 views

06 Jun 2020

Community Sentiment

17 votes

MEDIUM INTEREST

Positive24%

Neutral12%

Negative65%

Get instant alerts · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

View Feedback

Project Gallery

Sentiment Analysis

Total Votes

Feedback Items

24%

12%

65%

Positive (24%)

Neutral (12%)

Negative (65%)

Positive Feedback

Appreciation for the colors in the set.
The set has potential as a sailing themed design.
Support for the designer as a newcomer to the community.
Interest in the project's development with a desire for more details.

Negative Feedback

Concerns about the overall color cohesion.
Criticism about the lack of structure and inspiration behind the set.
Feedback suggesting the designs feel derivative of existing sets.
Concerns that the post lacks completeness and does not inspire confidence for a group buy.
Comments about the gradient keycaps feeling like an afterthought.
Suggestions for more thematic coherence to strengthen the design.
Observation that the rendering of the board is not appealing.
Indications that the colors do not work well together.
General lack of excitement for the current design.

Suggestions

Rework the color choices for better appeal.
Add more clarity and completeness to the initial post.
Consider incorporating thematic references to improve the set's viability.
Seek feedback from experienced designers for better IC and GB preparation.

Common Questions

Inquiry about the inspiration behind the keycap set.
Request for clarification on intended kits and designs.

🤖 AI Summary

The thread contains a total of 17 comments with a strong presence of negative feedback and a significant number of suggestions for improvement. Positive feedback acknowledges potential and supports the designer's efforts. The overall engagement is moderate, resulting in a 'medium' interest level.