KeycapMEDIUM INTEREST
GMK Magnolia (Pre-IC)
GMK Magnolia is a new keycap concept inspired by Magnolia flowers, developed by a budding designer as their fourth project. The design includes a base set with customized colors, alphas, mod-legends, accents, and mods. Feedback is welcomed to refine the concept.
30 replies
13,833 views
13 May 2021
Community Sentiment
30 votes
Positive23%
Neutral47%
Negative30%
Get instant alerts · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Project Gallery
Sentiment Analysis
30
Total Votes
21
Feedback Items
23%
47%
30%
Positive (23%)
Neutral (47%)
Negative (30%)
Positive Feedback
- The colors are really nice.
- This is such a pretty set! Keep up the good work!
- I quite like the colour scheme.
- I would definitely buy this.
- The colors are nice.
- I like the colour scheme and the icon only mods.
- This basekit render is better than some stuff that's made it to this site.
Negative Feedback
- It possibly attracts newer designers to do the same or even become a usual thing later on.
- Giving out the color codes before the set has even entered IC may lead to issues.
- Vendors aren't likely to pick up GMK sets from new designers.
- A pre-IC should include at least a board render.
- Stop bumping this.
- I'm not sure if I like the idea of a Pre-IC in this subforum.
- Wrong subforum.
- Are we interest checking the interest check?
- It needs many things to become a complete IC.
Suggestions
- Consider RALs over Pantone if you must run as GMK.
- Include at least one novelty to show the type of direction for the project.
- Just say IC instead of Pre-IC.
Common Questions
- Where should a 'sanity check' just to see how others feel about the color scheme and/or initial kitting go?
- Are we interest checking the interest check so we can check the interest for the interest check?
🤖 AI Summary
The thread has a balanced mix of feedback and indicates moderate community engagement despite the pre-IC status. There are multiple off-topic posts, but the overall nature of discussion shows genuine interest.
Interest Check Info
Project Specs
12
Specs Listed
Name
GMK MagnoliaRelease year
Profile
CherrySculpted
trueMaterial
ABSLayout Standard
Sub-Legends
Wall thickness
Legend method
DoubleshotColor palette
Magnolia-inspired colorsShine through
falsePudding style
false