KeycapMEDIUM INTEREST

GMK Gunfight

GMK Gunfight is inspired by old styled wild-west gunfights. Although no longer working on this design, the creator appreciates the experience gained and seeks feedback for future projects. The set features various kits, novelties, and keyboard renders.

75 replies

18,591 views

01 Apr 2021

Community Sentiment

48 votes

MEDIUM INTEREST

Positive25%

Neutral29%

Negative46%

Get instant alerts · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

View Feedback

Project Gallery

Sentiment Analysis

Total Votes

Feedback Items

25%

29%

46%

Positive (25%)

Neutral (29%)

Negative (46%)

Positive Feedback

This is developing so well!
I love cowboys and I'm super interested in this set.
New colors look very good.
Looks really good.
I do agree that the community should strive towards constructive criticism.
Good luck working on your set! You're on the right track!
Waiting for the new novelties.
I agree with everything you said in terms of recommendations.
This set is an opportunity for you to make something great.
I would have been down if the entire kit was the color of the mod keys.
The colors are much better this time around.
Beyond a doubt the best part is the community support!

Negative Feedback

The colors look like poop.
This is the most rushed and low quality set I've seen.
Had to make an April fools joke?
The scaling seems stretched which slightly raises a red flag.
I don't trust OP enough.
Unwarranted negative remarks are not needed.
It's disappointing to see the comments on this thread.
The set idea seems poor but could be improved.
This is an April Fools set.
I am hoping you develop the theme a bit more.
The colors don't work well together.
The novelty renders have artifacting.

Suggestions

Consider making 1u novelties for coverage on 65/75 layouts.
Adding an R3 1.25u tab key for basic coverage.
Rethink the colors used in the set for better contrast.
Renaming the set to something more fitting.
Look into using textured novelties.
Improve the novelty renders.
Explore potential community resources for design help.
Take more time to develop and polish the set.
Focus on creating designs that evoke the right emotions.
Consider feedback about kitting changes.

Common Questions

Do the novelties have textures?
Can you reiterate what the GMK Witch situation was about?
What process should be followed to refine my designs?
Has the concept been rushed without proper review?
What are the next steps in the development of the project?

🤖 AI Summary

The thread has a total of 48 comments. Sentiment distribution shows a predominance of negative feedback, mainly due to skepticism about the designer's intent and quality issues. However, there's significant interest in the cowboy theme which keeps the interest level at medium. The comments show a mix of support and challenges to the quality and execution of the set.