GMK EVIL08 (IC)

Keycap

8,361 views•29 replies

The GMK EVIL08 keycap set blends elements from GMK Evil Dolch and GMK 8008, aiming to create a unique combination. The designer is curious about public interest, acknowledging potential criticism for drawing on popular sets. Feedback is openly encouraged.

Community Sentiment

Medium Interest

Positive17%

Neutral24%

Negative59%

Project Gallery

Community Feedback & Sentiment

Medium Interest

Positive–17%•Neutral–24%•Negative–59%

Positive (5)

"Some community members find the idea funny."
"A comment states it could be the best set of the year."
"One user encourages checking for interest despite roughness."
"A comment mentions it being entertaining despite criticisms."
"Another user suggests exploring the project's unique concept."

Negative (5)

"Several comments criticize the design as a cash grab."
"Users express that the project needs more work and actual designs."
"Criticism for not asking permission from original set designers."
"Comments highlight that it's just a mix of two existing sets."
"Concerns about not having adequate design preparation before posting."

Suggestions (5)

Include iso support and numpad options in the design.
Consider refining the design more before an interest check.
Ask permission from creators of the original sets.
Engage with the community about expectations in IC threads.
Utilize resources in the Keycap Designer Discord.

Questions (5)

Why would permission be needed for this design?
What feedback is expected from the community at this stage?
What makes this idea a cash grab?
Is there interest in this design despite its rough state?
What particular features should the design include?

AI-Generated Insight – This summary is generated by AI based on community comments. Please verify details directly in the thread.

Duckeebs Analysis

The thread includes a mix of supportive and critical feedback, revealing a polarized sentiment. Despite the majority of negative comments, there are notable positive responses. Interest level is assessed as medium due to the number of unique replies and engagement.