KeycapMEDIUM INTEREST

GMK Doll 自动人偶 (Pre-IC)

KeyboardDaily, a popular media from China, introduces their first keycap design, GMK Doll, inspired by the anime Violet Evergarden. The design aims to capture the essence of expressing emotions through a typewriter, similar to the anime's main character, Violet, the Auto Memory Doll.

30 replies

10,537 views

16 May 2021

Community Sentiment

25 votes

MEDIUM INTEREST

Positive24%

Neutral28%

Negative48%

Get instant alerts · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

View Feedback

Project Gallery

Sentiment Analysis

Total Votes

Feedback Items

24%

28%

48%

Positive (24%)

Neutral (28%)

Negative (48%)

Positive Feedback

Love the colors and potential of the keycap set.
Hope to see a more completed version soon.
Looks great, especially with a potential typewriter keycap novelty.
The colors remind me of the character.
This has potential, hoping it's developed further.
Good luck and take time to refine the concept.

Negative Feedback

Criticism about the concept being underdeveloped.
Concerns about the trend of posting pre-ICs.
Presentation is perceived as poor and lacking effort.
Accusations of copying from Geekhack without credit.
Discussions about poor work ethic reflected in the pre-IC.
Expressed dislike for the entire concept.
Concerns of community backlash and harsh criticisms.

Suggestions

Request to flesh out the IC with better kitting and renders.
Emphasis on improving the overall presentation and research.
Encouragement to develop the concept fully before re-posting.
Advice to consider the impression the submission gives about work ethic.

Common Questions

Inquiries about the intent behind posting the pre-IC.
Questions regarding the community's harsh feedback.
Clarifications requested on the keycap theme and its relation to the anime.

🤖 AI Summary

The thread contained a mix of heavy criticism and some positive encouragement. Overall community engagement shows divided feelings about the concept and execution, with several requests for improvements. Interest level indicated by a fair number of replies, though many were negative.