KeycapMEDIUM INTEREST

GMK CYL Scáthach

The GMK CYL Scáthach keycap set is inspired by a mythological Scottish warrior, featuring custom colors and unique novelties. This Cherry profile doubleshot ABS set includes a base kit and a novelty kit.

29 replies

11,052 views

15 Jun 2023

Community Sentiment

23 votes

MEDIUM INTEREST

Positive30%

Neutral30%

Negative39%

Get instant alerts · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

View Feedback

Project Gallery

Sentiment Analysis

Total Votes

Feedback Items

30%

39%

Positive (30%)

Neutral (30%)

Negative (39%)

Positive Feedback

Some users appreciate the color choices and styles, finding them appealing.
One commenter expresses general enjoyment of the concept.
Another finds the design to be cute and reminiscent of a favorite character.
A user values the idea of including more lore to make the set more interesting.
Support for the inclusion of various sublegend styles like Ogham.
One comment sees the design as visually acceptable and fit for the character.

Negative Feedback

Multiple users criticize the washed-out colors that don't match the character's portrayal.
Concerns about the lack of novelty and insufficient connection to the source material.
Criticism over the choice of sublegend styles over preferred alternatives.
One user expresses boredom with the overall theme.
Comments about the need for more novelties and custom icons instead of text.
Frustration expressed regarding the naming of the profile and its confusion.

Suggestions

Users suggest the inclusion of runic sublegends instead of the current options.
Recommendation for more saturated colors to match the character better.
Suggestions to add more 1U keys to increase set variety without high cost.
A user encourages deeper exploration of the character's lore in design.
Calls for icons instead of text on the sublegends.

Common Questions

Inquires on whether the GMK has ever offered an Irish layout.
Questions about the reasoning behind specific design choices for mods.
Requests for details on the choice of sublegend types used.
Asks about how community members can indicate a lack of interest.

🤖 AI Summary

The thread has mixed sentiment with active engagement, leading to a medium interest level. Feedback showed a strong community involvement but significant critique about the aesthetics and thematic relevance of the keycap set.